STUDY TEAM

ACCIDENT

METHODS

RESULTS

1

Shell Moerdijk (2014)

Storybuilder, STEP, Accimap, CAST

 Final Report

AABE Assessment

Methods Evaluation (Storybuilder)

3

Toxic cloud in Belgium

French/English

BARPI’s Method – ARIA 3

AABE Assessment

Methods Evaluation

4

BP Texas City (2005)

Organisational Analysis of Safety

AABE Assessment

Methods Evaluation

6 Nuclear

Fukushima (Natech)

Fault Tree, Event Tree

AABE Assessment

Methods Evaluation

Fukushima analysis by Daisuke Uesako

6 Chemical 

Cosmo Refinery (Natech)

STEP, Event and Causal Factors Charting,

Barrier analysis on a Tier-based sorting

6 Chemical 

JX Refinery (Natech)

STEP, Fault Tree, Event Tree, MTO

7

Buncefield (2005)

STEP, Tripod Beta, Accimap, CAST

AABE Assessment - Accimap and Tripod Beta

AABE Assessment - CAST

Methods Evaluation

8

Tianjin (2015)

Bow Tie, Accimap

AABE Assessment

Methods Evaluation

Method

New URL

Storybuilder

http://tiny.cc/Story

ARIA 3 (BARPI method)

Organisational Analysis of Safety (OAoS)

ECFA (Events and Causal Factors Analysis)

ETBA (Energy Trace and Barrier Analysis)

MORT (Management and Oversight Tree)

http://tiny.cc/MORT1

ESReDA Cube

http://tiny.cc/Cube

Chronology Description

Event Tree (ETA)

http://tiny.cc/ETA

Fault Tree (FTA)

http://tiny.cc/FTA1

STEP (Sequential Timed Events Plotting)

http://tiny.cc/STEP10 (P45)

DISC (Design for Integrated Safety Culture)

https://tinyurl.com/y23r2djn

MTO (Man, Technology and Organisation)

http://tiny.cc/MTO10 (P50)

ECFC (Event and Causal Factors Charting)

http://tiny.cc/ECFC10 (P27)

Barrier Analysis

http://tiny.cc/barrier1 (P30)

Root cause on a tiered sorting basis

Tripod Beta

http://tiny.cc/tripodbeta (P56)

CAST (Causal Analysis using System Theory)

http://tiny.cc/CAST1

Accimap

http://tiny.cc/accimap

Bow-Tie

http://tiny.cc/bowtie1